Osias Beert the Elder, Dishes with Oysters, Fruit, and Wine, c. 1620–1624. National Gallery of Art, Patrons’ Permanent Fund. Before the turkey is carved, there is that lovely stretch of Thanksgiving when everyone gathers in the kitchen. Someone is checking the potatoes. Someone has brought a pie. Someone is asking what they can do to help. Bring out a tray of oysters, and you have an answer: pull up a chair. Oysters give the holiday something to gather around, whether they arrive baked with herb butter, tucked into a savory dressing, or ladled into small bowls of stew. They also come with a story. Their place at Thanksgiving belongs to a much longer history of coastal cooking, generous tables, and cooks finding delicious ways to feed a crowd. To understand how oysters found their way beside the turkey, it helps to begin well before Thanksgiving. Before Thanksgiving, oysters were already on the menu In medieval England, oysters appeared in The Forme of Cury, a collection of recipes composed around 1390 for Richard II’s household. One preparation simmered them with wine and their own broth, adding almonds, rice flour, ginger, and mace. A bowl of oysters with warming spices would have tasted quite different from today’s lemon-and-mignonette platter, but the instinct to make something special of them is familiar. British Library manuscript history · The historical oyster recipe Later English cookbooks put oysters in the company of festive poultry. The 1685 edition of Robert May’s The Accomplisht Cook begins its suggested New Year’s Day menu with oysters and includes capons and turkeys among the dishes that follow. In the eighteenth century, Hannah Glasse recommended oyster sauce for roast or boiled turkey and other fowl. Oysters and a holiday bird were already comfortable companions in British cooking well before the American national Thanksgiving holiday took shape. Robert May’s New Year’s menu · Hannah Glasse’s oyster sauce Those recipes offer a useful backdrop to Thanksgiving oyster traditions. Across the Atlantic, however, oysters already had a history of their own. What about the 1621 harvest gathering? Long before English settlement, Wampanoag people gathered food from New England’s coastal waters. Plimoth Patuxet Museums describes women harvesting oysters alongside clams, mussels, and other shellfish. The region’s oyster story begins with that knowledge of the shore, seasons, and tides. Wampanoag foodways at Plimoth Patuxet Museums Whether oysters were served at the 1621 gathering at Patuxet, now Plymouth, is another question. Edward Winslow’s account mentions fowl and the five deer brought by a Wampanoag party led by Ousamequin, also known as Massasoit. Elsewhere in the same letter, Winslow says the colonists had no oysters nearby, although Indigenous people could bring them. He does not tell us whether oysters appeared at the feast. Edward Winslow’s December 1621 letter We may never settle the 1621 menu. Yours is easier: bring the oysters. Fortunately, their place on later Thanksgiving tables is much easier to trace. How oysters earned their place beside the turkey By the nineteenth century, American cooks had plenty of reasons to work oysters into a meal. In New York City, they were plentiful and affordable enough to be everyday food. Rail transport also carried live Eastern oysters far beyond the coast, widening the market for them. New York City Municipal Archives on the oyster trade · Smithsonian account of live oyster shipments The familiar Thanksgiving menu was taking shape during that century, too. Abraham Lincoln called for a national Thanksgiving on the last Thursday of November in 1863. Later cookbooks give us a particularly appetizing view of the holiday table. Lincoln’s Thanksgiving proclamation The White House Cook Book, first published in 1887, lists oysters on the half shell at the start of its suggested Thanksgiving dinner, followed by dishes including roast turkey, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes, and pumpkin pie. Its Thanksgiving supper menu includes scalloped oysters. These suggested menus give home cooks a clear place for oysters at the holiday table. See the Thanksgiving menus The same cookbook includes oyster dressing made with bread, butter, herbs, and chopped oysters. It is easy to understand the appeal: bread catches the savory juices, herbs bring the familiar fragrance of Thanksgiving, and oysters give the dish a taste of the coast. A spoonful beside the turkey connects two ingredients with a long history together. The cookbook’s oyster dressing Thanksgiving dinner menu from the Proteus Club Cook Book, 1900. Library of Congress. A tradition you can make your own If oyster dressing never appeared at your family’s Thanksgiving, this is a lovely year to introduce it. If it was your grandmother’s specialty, bringing it back might be the dish that gets everyone talking. There is no need to replace the stuffing people wait all year to eat. Add a smaller oyster dish alongside it, or give oysters their own moment before dinner. For inspiration, a few familiar names offer different ways to welcome them to the table: Martha Stewart’s Oyster and Cracker Dressing combines oysters, crackers, and cream in a baked holiday side. James Beard’s Oyster Stew brings together oysters, butter, milk, cream, and a touch of cayenne. Beard associated the dish with Christmas Eve; small cups would also make a welcoming Thanksgiving first course. Emeril Lagasse’s Oyster Dressing takes a bolder direction with peppers, garlic, hot sauce, and Worcestershire. Consider that flavor profile if your family enjoys a little heat with its holiday meal. These recipes show how much room there is within the tradition. You can keep the menu quiet and classic, lean into a rich dressing, or give your guests a lively bite before they sit down. At our table, we would start with herb-butter baked oysters while guests arrive, serve a small dish of sage oyster dressing with the turkey, and leave plenty of room for pie. For a more relaxed gathering, warm mugs of oyster stew and good bread make a generous opening act. Pick one idea that suits your kitchen and the people coming over. Explore our five Thanksgiving oyster recipes. Bring a little Great Bay to Thanksgiving The best reason to revive a food tradition is the pleasure of sharing it. Someone remembers a family recipe. Someone tries an oyster for the first time. A dish that felt unfamiliar this year becomes the one everyone requests next year. For a New England Thanksgiving, Great Bay oysters bring a local connection to that story. Order ahead from New England Superior Oyster and tell us when you need them. We’ll coordinate availability and pickup timing with you, keeping an eye on weather and harvest conditions as the holiday approaches. Add “Thanksgiving” and your preferred pickup day to your order note, and wait for your separate Ready for Pickup notice before collecting your oysters in Dover. Order Great Bay oysters for your Thanksgiving table. Then send this story to the person who always asks, “What can I bring?”
Osias Beert the Elder, Dishes with Oysters, Fruit, and Wine, c. 1620–1624. National Gallery of Art, Patrons’ Permanent Fund. Before the turkey is carved, there is that lovely stretch of Thanksgiving when everyone gathers in the kitchen. Someone is checking the potatoes. Someone has brought a pie. Someone is asking what they can do to help. Bring out a tray of oysters, and you have an answer: pull up a chair. Oysters give the holiday something to gather around, whether they arrive baked with herb butter, tucked into a savory dressing, or ladled into small bowls of stew. They also come with a story. Their place at Thanksgiving belongs to a much longer history of coastal cooking, generous tables, and cooks finding delicious ways to feed a crowd. To understand how oysters found their way beside the turkey, it helps to begin well before Thanksgiving. Before Thanksgiving, oysters were already on the menu In medieval England, oysters appeared in The Forme of Cury, a collection of recipes composed around 1390 for Richard II’s household. One preparation simmered them with wine and their own broth, adding almonds, rice flour, ginger, and mace. A bowl of oysters with warming spices would have tasted quite different from today’s lemon-and-mignonette platter, but the instinct to make something special of them is familiar. British Library manuscript history · The historical oyster recipe Later English cookbooks put oysters in the company of festive poultry. The 1685 edition of Robert May’s The Accomplisht Cook begins its suggested New Year’s Day menu with oysters and includes capons and turkeys among the dishes that follow. In the eighteenth century, Hannah Glasse recommended oyster sauce for roast or boiled turkey and other fowl. Oysters and a holiday bird were already comfortable companions in British cooking well before the American national Thanksgiving holiday took shape. Robert May’s New Year’s menu · Hannah Glasse’s oyster sauce Those recipes offer a useful backdrop to Thanksgiving oyster traditions. Across the Atlantic, however, oysters already had a history of their own. What about the 1621 harvest gathering? Long before English settlement, Wampanoag people gathered food from New England’s coastal waters. Plimoth Patuxet Museums describes women harvesting oysters alongside clams, mussels, and other shellfish. The region’s oyster story begins with that knowledge of the shore, seasons, and tides. Wampanoag foodways at Plimoth Patuxet Museums Whether oysters were served at the 1621 gathering at Patuxet, now Plymouth, is another question. Edward Winslow’s account mentions fowl and the five deer brought by a Wampanoag party led by Ousamequin, also known as Massasoit. Elsewhere in the same letter, Winslow says the colonists had no oysters nearby, although Indigenous people could bring them. He does not tell us whether oysters appeared at the feast. Edward Winslow’s December 1621 letter We may never settle the 1621 menu. Yours is easier: bring the oysters. Fortunately, their place on later Thanksgiving tables is much easier to trace. How oysters earned their place beside the turkey By the nineteenth century, American cooks had plenty of reasons to work oysters into a meal. In New York City, they were plentiful and affordable enough to be everyday food. Rail transport also carried live Eastern oysters far beyond the coast, widening the market for them. New York City Municipal Archives on the oyster trade · Smithsonian account of live oyster shipments The familiar Thanksgiving menu was taking shape during that century, too. Abraham Lincoln called for a national Thanksgiving on the last Thursday of November in 1863. Later cookbooks give us a particularly appetizing view of the holiday table. Lincoln’s Thanksgiving proclamation The White House Cook Book, first published in 1887, lists oysters on the half shell at the start of its suggested Thanksgiving dinner, followed by dishes including roast turkey, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes, and pumpkin pie. Its Thanksgiving supper menu includes scalloped oysters. These suggested menus give home cooks a clear place for oysters at the holiday table. See the Thanksgiving menus The same cookbook includes oyster dressing made with bread, butter, herbs, and chopped oysters. It is easy to understand the appeal: bread catches the savory juices, herbs bring the familiar fragrance of Thanksgiving, and oysters give the dish a taste of the coast. A spoonful beside the turkey connects two ingredients with a long history together. The cookbook’s oyster dressing Thanksgiving dinner menu from the Proteus Club Cook Book, 1900. Library of Congress. A tradition you can make your own If oyster dressing never appeared at your family’s Thanksgiving, this is a lovely year to introduce it. If it was your grandmother’s specialty, bringing it back might be the dish that gets everyone talking. There is no need to replace the stuffing people wait all year to eat. Add a smaller oyster dish alongside it, or give oysters their own moment before dinner. For inspiration, a few familiar names offer different ways to welcome them to the table: Martha Stewart’s Oyster and Cracker Dressing combines oysters, crackers, and cream in a baked holiday side. James Beard’s Oyster Stew brings together oysters, butter, milk, cream, and a touch of cayenne. Beard associated the dish with Christmas Eve; small cups would also make a welcoming Thanksgiving first course. Emeril Lagasse’s Oyster Dressing takes a bolder direction with peppers, garlic, hot sauce, and Worcestershire. Consider that flavor profile if your family enjoys a little heat with its holiday meal. These recipes show how much room there is within the tradition. You can keep the menu quiet and classic, lean into a rich dressing, or give your guests a lively bite before they sit down. At our table, we would start with herb-butter baked oysters while guests arrive, serve a small dish of sage oyster dressing with the turkey, and leave plenty of room for pie. For a more relaxed gathering, warm mugs of oyster stew and good bread make a generous opening act. Pick one idea that suits your kitchen and the people coming over. Explore our five Thanksgiving oyster recipes. Bring a little Great Bay to Thanksgiving The best reason to revive a food tradition is the pleasure of sharing it. Someone remembers a family recipe. Someone tries an oyster for the first time. A dish that felt unfamiliar this year becomes the one everyone requests next year. For a New England Thanksgiving, Great Bay oysters bring a local connection to that story. Order ahead from New England Superior Oyster and tell us when you need them. We’ll coordinate availability and pickup timing with you, keeping an eye on weather and harvest conditions as the holiday approaches. Add “Thanksgiving” and your preferred pickup day to your order note, and wait for your separate Ready for Pickup notice before collecting your oysters in Dover. Order Great Bay oysters for your Thanksgiving table. Then send this story to the person who always asks, “What can I bring?”




Comments